When it comes to maintaining a printer, whether for personal use or within a business setting, the choice of toner cartridges can significantly affect both printing costs and print quality. Choosing the right toner cartridges ensures not only efficient printing but also contributes to the longevity of your printer, making it a key decision for any printing operation. This blog explores the cost differences between HP toner cartridges and generic brands, exploring not only the upfront costs but also the long term benefits and potential drawbacks of each option.

Understanding Cost Per Print

Cost per print is a crucial factor when considering whether to purchase original HP toner cartridges or opt for generic alternatives. This metric calculates the average cost to print a single page, factoring in the price of the toner and the yield  or the number of pages the toner can produce.


HP toner cartridges are renowned for their reliability and high yield. Although they might have a higher upfront cost compared to generic brands, they often offer a greater page yield, which can lower the cost per print in the long run. HP also frequently updates their cartridge technology to provide optimal compatibility and efficiency.


Generic or third party toner cartridges are typically less expensive upfront. However, their cost per print can be higher if the cartridge has a lower page yield or if it requires frequent replacements. Additionally, the quality of print and consistency can vary widely among different generic brands.

Quality of Print

Quality is another significant aspect to consider. HP toner cartridges are designed specifically for HP printers, ensuring that each print is sharp, clear, and consistent. Using HP toner cartridges helps maintain the longevity of your printer, reducing the risk of damage or malfunction caused by incompatible or low-quality cartridges.


With HP toner cartridges you can expect high quality prints with vibrant colours and crisp text. HP cartridges are also designed to work seamlessly with HP printers, avoiding common issues such as smudging, streaking, or uneven toner distribution.


With generic brands the print quality can be hit or miss, depending on the brand and compatibility with the printer. Some users report excellent results, while others encounter problems that can compromise the look of the printed page, potentially reflecting poorly in professional environments.

Printer Health and Maintenance

The long term health of a printer is arguably just as important as the cost and quality of prints. Using toner cartridges that are fully compatible with your printer can extend its lifespan and minimise maintenance issues. HP toner cartridges are designed to work perfectly with HP printers, these cartridges help maintain the longevity of the printer. 

HP ensures that their toners do not cause unnecessary wear and tear on the printing mechanisms. Whereas with generic brands there is a risk that generic cartridges could lead to increased maintenance issues. These might include clogging, incorrect toner levels, and even damage to the printer over time, which could void any initial savings due to increased repair and replacement costs.

Environmental Considerations

HP is committed to sustainability, often recycling used cartridges and designing new ones that are more environmentally friendly. Generic brands may not always have the same level of commitment to environmental sustainability, which is a factor to consider for eco conscious consumers. In addition to recycling used cartridges and designing eco-friendly options, HP also invests in reducing carbon emissions throughout its supply chain, further demonstrating its dedication to environmental sustainability.

Count on Your HP Toner Cartridges

Choosing between HP toner cartridges and generic brands comes down to evaluating the total cost of ownership; including the cost per print, print quality, impact on printer health, and environmental factors. For those relying on their printers for high quality and professional looking documents, the investment in HP cartridges can be justified not only by the superior print output and reliability but also by the savings in maintenance and potential printer replacement costs.

For businesses, in particular, where the smooth operation of printing devices can impact workflow and productivity, opting for original HP products can provide peace of mind and value over time. Meanwhile, individual users or those with minimal printing needs might opt for generics as a cost saving measure. However, it's essential to select reputable generic brands to avoid the pitfalls of poor quality and potential printer damage.

Get in Touch

That said, should you decide that HP toner cartridges are the best solution for you going forward, then why not head over to the Toner One website or get in touch with our knowledgeable experts directly to find out more about our available stock of HP toner cartridges. This can be done by giving us a call on 01462 233 669, by sending us an email to admin@tonerone.co.uk. Alternatively complete our online enquiry form and we will be happy to help you secure your required HP toner cartridges for the most competitive price around.
Comparing the cost of hp toner cartridges and generic brands